Starbucks cracks down on freeloaders to reverse sales decline

Unlock Editor’s Digest for free

FT editor Roula Khalaf selects her favorite stories in this weekly newsletter.

A man in a winter coat enters a crowded Starbucks cafe and lounges on a caramel-colored seat. Then he got up, went to the bathroom and exited into a frigid downtown Manhattan.

One thing he doesn’t do is buy a drink. Effective Monday, Starbucks plans to change that.

The world’s largest coffee shop chain is introducing new policies that operate nearly 11,000 stores across North America. Free cups of water are out. Ceramic mugs or glasses will have free coffee refills.

Customers will now be defined as purchasing persons. Those who are not asked to leave.

Starbucks Acting with urgency. Its North American locations grew by 5 percent less trading in 2024, the first annual decline since the pandemic year of 2020.

Analysts polled by Visible Alpha expected same-store sales to fall 4.8 percent in fiscal first-quarter results due Tuesday.

Chief Executive Brian Niccol has begun a turnaround plan that he calls a “return to Starbucks.” The name is nostalgic: He’s trying to make Starbucks a “community coffeehouse” again, a place that’s long-lasting and comfortable for brotherhood.

But it’s also literal: Starbucks needs to get more paying customers back inside its stores.

Last week, baristas sat through three hours of training sessions to implement a new “code of conduct” that began appearing in stores.

A version of the code posted on the window of the New York cafe last week said the store was “for use by our partners and customers (people shopping and accompanying people) – this includes our cafes, patios and restrooms”.

Law enforcement was requested as an alternative to remove those who did not comply.

In 2018, Starbucks announced after a few weeks of controversy whether a customer had made a purchase or not. arrested Two black men asked to use the restroom before making a purchase at a store in Philadelphia.

This month’s policy reversal is stoking its own concerns.

Donald Whitehead, executive director of the National Coalition for the Homeless, said his advocacy group will petition the agency to reconsider. He said Starbucks sometimes served as a “buffer” location for the homeless during the morning hours, after shelters emptied and before libraries opened for the day.

“We don’t need less resources. We need more,” he said. “I know that Starbucks is not responsible for the welfare of the homeless population, but we are very concerned.”

Workers United, the labor union representing baristas at 538 stores, has called on the company to let Code of Conduct enforcers participate in formal negotiations over new work contracts. a X post It argued that “workers and customers are getting nickeled and dimed” as free water and open access to restrooms disappear.

Michelle Eisen, a barista and union organizer and bargaining representative, said she and her colleagues “would have a hard time telling a homeless person in Buffalo, New York when it’s not negative 3 degrees that they can’t sit in our cafe, they can’t sit in our cafe for 10 minutes and it’s hot. Up, because they can’t make any purchases it’s going to be a very difficult thing for me to continue”.

Starbucks says it’s not setting a time limit for visitors to buy: Employees aren’t expected to quietly interfere with a guest using a table in an empty store.

However, a visitor may be approached and asked to make a purchase in a crowded store where customers are waiting to be seated.

Most retailers have codes of conduct, the company said, and its own will help “prioritize our paying customers who want to enjoy our cafe or use the restroom while they visit.”

“The behavior change code is Brian Nicol making Starbucks more of an industry standard,” said Guggenheim Securities analyst Gregory Fransfort.

Nikkal to introduce He joined the company in September and has since spelled out the goals, including condensing the menu with a separate queue for mobile order pick-ups and a four-minute goal to fulfill orders placed in cafes to “get back to Starbucks”.

He wants to recapture some of the warmth that was lost as Starbucks focused on app-based business and ditched the comfy chairs to streamline operations. Other changes offered Monday include the return of “condiment bars” with creams and sweeteners for customers to choose from.

Angel Robinson-Gaylord, America’s senior vice president of store development, told a commercial real estate conference in December that a team of more than 750 people working on the redesign to include what you see, what, what will open fewer new stores this year a full You smell to create a sensory experience, you smell what you hear.

The experience was harsh last week at a Starbucks outlet in New York. Seat includes lower windowsill warmed by HVAC ducts running below.

Some of the 15 or so spectators sipped drinks or waited for their names to be called by baristas filling orders. Others seemed interested in products for sale. One sat by the bathroom door watching a video on his phone.

Bryant Simon, author Everything But Coffee: Learning About America From StarbucksNikkel’s push to reestablish the chain as a community hub has revealed a contradiction.

“That’s the catch and difficulty in building community,” he said. “Not everybody wants everybody there.”